• Local Grubber
  • Posts
  • The Top Bagel Shops on Long Island: A Carb-Lover's Guide

The Top Bagel Shops on Long Island: A Carb-Lover's Guide

Long Island is a haven for bagel aficionados. Some would argue that we have the best bagels in the world. Countless shops battle for the title of "Island's Best." I've embarked on a delicious journey to sample the top contenders and bring you the ultimate guide to Long Island's best bagel shops.

Sponsored
BestSelf Compass’ NewsletterInsider Secrets + Travel Tips to Unlocking Luxury Vacations for FREE!

Here are my top picks, each offering a unique twist on the classic New York bagel experience:

  1. Bagel Boss (Hicksville)

  • Claim to Fame: A Long Island institution, Bagel Boss is famous for their 24/7 service and wide variety of flavors, including the trademarked "flagel" - a flatter, crunchier take on the bagel.

  • Yelp Review

  • Website 

  • TripAdvisor Review

  1. A&S Bagels (Franklin Square)

  • Claim to Fame: A&S offers classic New York-style bagels alongside fun flavors like blueberry, sun-dried tomato, and jalapeno. They're also open 24/7 and even ship nationwide!

  • Yelp Review

  • Website: 

  • TripAdvisor Review

  1. Blazin' Bagel & Deli (Manorville)

  • Claim to Fame: This newcomer has quickly gained a loyal following for their commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their bagels are hand-crafted and boast the perfect balance of chew and crisp.

  • Yelp Review

  • Restaurant Guru

  • Claim to Fame: This local favorite offers a wide selection of bagels and breakfast options, with weekly specials and catering services. Their dedication to fresh ingredients shines through in every bite.

  • Yelp Review

  • Website

  • TripAdvisor Review

  • Claim to Fame: This family-owned shop boasts a loyal following for their hand-rolled bagels, always fresh out of the oven. Their nova lox bagel sandwich is a must-try!

  • Yelp Review

  • Website

  • TripAdvisor Review

  • Claim to Fame: This friendly neighborhood spot offers classic New York-style bagels at affordable prices. They're a great choice for a quick and delicious breakfast or lunch.

  • Yelp Review

  • Website

  • TripAdvisor Review

  • Claim to Fame: A mainstay in the Great Neck community, Best Bagels offers fresh bagels, familiar deli fare, and a casual atmosphere. They also cater, making them a great option for parties and events.

  • Yelp Review

  • Website

  • TripAdvisor Review

What is your Favorite Bagel Shop. Click Here to let me know

#foodwithaview #foodporn #foodie #foodstagram #foodpics #restaurantreview #reviewrestaurant #grub #grubbing #bagels

Reply

or to participate.