The Long Island Scoop: A Summer Adventure Through 10 Top-Rated Ice Cream Parlors

Long Island boasts a vibrant ice cream scene, offering a delightful selection of flavors and experiences for every sweet tooth. From classic parlors to trendy shops, here's a guide to the top ice cream parlors on Long Island, based on a combination of online reviews, local recommendations, and unique offerings:

1. Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream (Bay Shore & Islip): A Long Island institution, Coyle's serves up super-premium, homemade ice cream in a classic parlor setting. They're renowned for their innovative flavors and generous portions. (Pro tip: Try the "Captain Crunch" for a nostalgic kick!)

Review snippets:

• "The best ice cream on Long Island! The portions are huge and the flavors are always delicious." - Yelp Reviews

• "This place is a must-visit for any ice cream lover. The homemade waffle cones are amazing too!" - Google Maps Review

2. Old Fashioned Ice Cream (West Babylon): This family-friendly spot offers classic ice cream flavors, milkshakes, and sundaes in a charming, old-fashioned setting. Perfect for a post-dinner treat or a casual afternoon outing.

Review snippets:

• "Great place for a classic ice cream experience. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable." - Yelp Review

• "This is our go-to spot for ice cream sundaes! The kids love it and the portions are perfect for sharing." - Google Maps Review

3. Lics Ice Cream (Northport): This modern ice cream shop focuses on unique and creative flavors, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. They also offer vegan options, ensuring everyone can indulge.

Review snippets:

• "The flavors here are incredible! They always have something new and exciting to try." - Yelp Review

• "Lics is a great option for anyone with dietary restrictions. Their vegan ice cream is delicious and creamy!" - Google Maps Review

4. Sweet Treats on the Wharf (Port Washington): Located right on the Port Washington waterfront, this delightful shop offers breathtaking views alongside their homemade ice cream. Perfect for a scenic treat after a stroll along the harbor.

Review snippets:

• "The ice cream is delicious, but the real star of the show is the view! Perfect for a summer evening." - Yelp Review

• "This is a hidden gem! The staff is friendly and the location is unbeatable." - Google Maps Review

5. McNulty's Ice Cream (Miller Place): This family-owned shop serves up classic flavors alongside some unique offerings, like lavender honey or peanut butter brownie. They also offer homemade waffle cones and baked goods.

Review snippets:

• "This is our favorite ice cream shop in Suffolk County. The ice cream is delicious and the staff is always friendly." - Yelp Review

• "McNulty's is a great place to bring the family. They have something for everyone!" - Google Maps Review

6. Strong Island Ice Cream (Greenport & Patchogue): This farm-to-cone creamery boasts fresh, local ingredients and unique seasonal flavors. They also offer dairy-free options using coconut milk.

Review snippets:

• "The best ice cream on the North Fork! The flavors are so fresh and unique." - Yelp Review

• "Strong Island is a great option for anyone looking for a delicious and healthy ice cream treat." - Google Maps Review

7. Milky Way's Ice Cream and Cereal Bar (Farmingdale): This quirky shop combines two breakfast favorites – ice cream and cereal! They offer a variety of creative toppings and mix-ins, perfect for the adventurous eater.

Review snippets:

• "Such a fun and unique concept! The ice cream is delicious and the cereal toppings are endless." - Yelp Review

• "This is a great place to take the kids for a fun and creative ice cream experience." - Google Maps Review

8. Gelateria Dei Coltelli (Williston Park): This Italian gem offers not just gelato, but also a variety of Italian pastries and desserts. Perfect for those seeking a taste of authentic Italian flavors.

Review snippets:

• "The gelato here is amazing! So creamy and flavorful. They also have a great selection of pastries." - Yelp Review

• "This is a great spot for a post-dinner dessert. The ambiance is lovely and the service is excellent." - Google Maps Review

9. Nana's Ice Cream & Coffee House (Westbury): This cozy spot offers homemade ice cream alongside coffee drinks and baked goods. It's a great place to relax and enjoy a sweet treat in a warm and inviting atmosphere.

Review snippets:

• "The perfect place to escape the hustle and bustle. Yelp Reviews

#foodwithaview #foodporn #foodie #foodstagram #foodpics #restaurantreview #reviewrestaurant #grub #grubbing