The Long Island Pastrami Pilgrimage: A Quest for the Holy Grail of Meaty Goodness

The Long Island Pastrami Pilgrimage: A Quest for the Holy Grail of Meaty Goodness

Long Island boasts a treasure trove of delis and restaurants, each vying for the title of "best pastrami sandwich." But with so many options, where does a dedicated pastrami lover begin? Fear not, fellow carnivores, for we embark on a delicious pilgrimage to discover the top pastrami sandwiches on Long Island!

The Classics: Where Tradition Reigns Supreme

• Ben's Kosher Delicatessen (Greenvale): A Long Island institution, Ben's has dominated the pastrami scene for decades. Their signature sandwich features house-made, melt-in-your-mouth pastrami piled high on fresh rye bread with tangy mustard and creamy Russian dressing. A true crowd-pleaser! (Reviewer quote: "The gold standard for pastrami on Long Island. A must-try for any deli lover!" - Yelp Review)

• Smok-Haus (Garden City): This newcomer has taken the pastrami world by storm, recently voted the best on Long Island. Their pastrami is house-brined for two weeks, then smoked overnight for an incredible depth of flavor. Served on toasted rye with their signature cheese sauce, it's a decadent and delicious experience. (Reviewer quote: "Smok-Haus lives up to the hype! The pastrami is smoky, juicy, and the cheese sauce is divine." - Yelp Review)

• Lido Kosher Deli (Lido Beach): Serving Long Island for nearly 60 years, Wally and the Goetz family have spent almost 30 years providing the community with great food and impeccable service. The best pastrami on Long Island. (Reviewer quote: "This is a must whenever we go home to Long Beach. A pastrami sandwich." - Yelp Review)

The Trendsetters: Modern Twists on a Beloved Dish

• Black Sheep Bar & Grill (Farmingdale): This neighborhood spot offers a monstrous pastrami Reuben. This behemoth features house-made pastrami, melty Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on toasted rye bread. It's a challenge to finish, but a delicious one! (Reviewer quote: "Black Sheep's Reuben is the stuff of legends. Be prepared to share (or come very hungry)!" - Yelp Review)

Hidden Gems & Local Favorites

• Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza (Multiple Locations): While known for their pizza, Anthony's offers a surprisingly delicious pastrami sandwich. Their thin-crust version features a generous portion of pastrami on a toasted hero roll, perfect for a casual and satisfying lunch. (Reviewer quote: "The perfect alternative to pizza! Anthony's pastrami hero is a great choice for a quick bite." - Yelp Review)

• Bay Shore Bagel & Deli (Bay Shore): This no-frills deli offers a classic pastrami sandwich at a great price. Their fresh-baked rye bread

#foodwithaview #foodporn #foodie #foodstagram #foodpics #restaurantreview #reviewrestaurant #grub #grubbing #pastrami