If you live on Long Island, you know that finding a reliable neighborhood pizza joint is essential. Recently, I decided to check out Americano Pizza Shop in Syosset. My verdict? It is definitely a solid spot that deserves a place in your rotation.
However, a word of advice before you go: your satisfaction here depends entirely on which style of pie you decide to order. This is a classic “choose your own adventure” scenario, and I’m here to make sure you choose the right path.
The Undisputed Champion: The Regular Round Pie
Let’s start with the good news, possibly, the great news. The clear winner at Americano Pizza Shop is their Regular Round Pie.
This isn’t just your ordinary, run-of-the-mill New York slice. It’s elevated. What really sets this pie apart is the sauce. It delivers an incredible, vibrant flavor profile that is immediately distinct from your average, bland pizza sauce.
Here is what makes this pie a total standout:
- Perfect Balance: There is an excellent, even ratio between the zesty sauce and the high-quality cheese.
- The Crunch Factor: Every bite finishes with a fantastic, satisfying crunch.
If you are looking for exactly what a classic, traditional New York round pie should be, this is it.
The Rating: 8.7 / 10
The Runner-Up: The Sicilian Pie
While the round pie soared, the Sicilian Pie unfortunately fell a bit short.
When you order a Sicilian, you expect a certain contrast—a crisp bottom with a light, airy interior. Unfortunately, this version didn’t quite measure up to their traditional option. The main issue was the dough; it came out a bit too thick and overly doughy, which became dense rather than fluffy and took away from the overall experience.
It’s not a bad pizza, but when compared to the excellence of the regular pie, it pales in comparison.
The Rating: A gentlemanly 6.2 / 10
The Final Verdict
If you are craving good pizza in Syosset, NY, head to Americano. But take my advice: stick to the regular round pie. Between that signature sauce and the perfect crustal crunch, you will not be disappointed.