If you are looking for the most beautiful dining room in Nassau County right now, The Farm Italy in Westbury is arguably the frontrunner. From the moment you walk in, the aesthetic is breathtaking. It is hard to believe that this space was the old Houlihan’s. The transformation is nothing short of breathtaking.
The interior bar is a genuine highlight, a massive marble centerpiece that feels like it belongs in an upscale Manhattan hotel. Add the outdoor firepit area, it will be a hard decision on where to have your pre-dinner drinks.
The Culinary Highs
The kitchen delivers mostly on the classic Italian cuisine.
- The Bread: It sounds simple, but the bread service here is exceptional. Fresh, artisanal, and served with high-quality oil, it’s the kind of starter that makes you optimistic for the rest of the meal. The only downside is that they charge you $10 for the bread.
- PappardelleBolognese: This is a must-order. The ragu is rich, deeply layered, and clings to perfectly al dente house-made pasta. It tastes like it’s been simmering for days.
- Chicken Parm: Executed to perfection. The breading remains crisp despite the generous coating of bright pomodoro and melted cheese. It’s a massive, satisfying portion that balances comfort with quality.
The Mid-Tier Miss
While the highs are very high, the Eggplant Parm unfortunately fell into the mediocre category. Compared to the brilliance of the chicken version, the eggplant felt a bit uninspired. The eggplant was too thick and it lacked the textural contrast and vibrancy found in the other dishes. In the end, this dish was a miss.
The Verdict
The Farm Italy is a stunning addition to Westbury. While one or two dishes might not reach the heights of their signature pastas, the overall experience, which is anchored by the incredible decor and those standout entrees, makes it desired destination. But with so many great Italian restaurants, it is hard to say that Farm Italy stands above its competition. But with that being said, definitely come for drinks at the bar and the firepit.
Rating: ★★★✬☆ (3.5/5) Vibe: Modern Chic with go dishes like Chicken Parm and PappardelleBolognese, and a cocktail by the fire.